How to Make Cowboy Boots Fit Tighter? | The 4 Easiest Ways to Do it

Welcome back to FromTheGuestRoom, we have introduced a lot of articles to solve many annoying problems with cowboy boots.

For example, How to break in cowboy boots, How to fix cowboy boots tight instep, How to stretch cowboy boots at home...

The common point of the above articles is that they solve the problem of tight cowboy boots.

So how about cowboy boots being loose? How to make cowboy boots fit tighter?

Let’s check it out!

How to make cowboy boots fit tighter?

Loose cowboy boots are nothing new to cowboy boot lovers and collectors. This will cause discomfort when you wear cowboy boots.

Cowboy boots often loose at the heel, instep or the tip, and these three wide areas will irritate you a lot.

What happens if you wear boots too big?

  • Heel slippage
  • Adversely affect your gait
  • Less confident while wearing boots
  • Lose flexibility when moving
  • Discomfort when walking
  • Cowboy boots fall out of your feet
  • Waste your money

How to fix it? Keep on reading.

1/ Methods to fix loose cowboy boots on the instep

When you choose cowboy boots, the instep is the crucial part you need to care about. The instep of cowboy boots should snugly fit, not loose and not tight.

However, you can’t avoid mistakes when you buy cowboy boots online, so how to fix this?

Method 1: Use extra cushion insole

This is a very popular way to fix a cowboy boot that is loose at the instep.

What you need is to lift your foot up, so there’s nothing better than using an extra cushion insole.

Besides, cushion insoles cradle your feet for comfortable wearing.

Read more: 8 Best Cowboy Boot Insoles

Method 2: Use thick socks

Another common method is using thick socks. Thick socks “lift” your feet significantly to fit the instep of cowboy boots.

You should wear sports socks rather than crowd your feet with two socks.

Sports socks usually have thicker footpads than other socks. Wearing two socks can work somehow, but your feet will get hot.

Dickies Men's Dri-tech Moisture Control Crew Socks Multipack, Black (12 Pairs), Shoe Size: 6-12
  • Soft Breathable Moisture Control Fibers
  • Arch Compression Support and Stability
  • Ventilation Channels Enhance Air Flow

Method 3: Use Ball of Foot Cushions

12-Pack Metatarsal Foot Pads for Pain Relief - 1/4” Thick, Ball of Foot Cushions for Women and Men, Forefoot and Sole Support, Metatarsalgia Mortons Neuroma
  • IMMEDIATE PAIN RELIEF - Our Metatarsal Foot Pads are specially designed to relieve the pain caused...
  • PODIATRIST RECOMMENDED - Same size and shape as the ball of foot pads prescribed by thousands of...
  • STRONG 3M ADHESIVE - These foot pads will stay in place through the day without leaving any sticky...

These patches can be used as cushion insoles to help your feet fit the instep of cowboy boots more.

However, the ball of foot cushions can be quite thin, you can insert two of them into cowboy boots.

Metatarsal Pads Ball of Foot Cushions - Soft Gel Ball of Foot Pads - Mortons Neuroma Callus Metatarsal Foot Pain Relief Bunion Forefoot Cushioning Relief Women Men - 2 Pairs
  • PREMIUM-QUALITY - Foot pads are made of high-quality, durable and very soft Eco-friendly medical...
  • COMFORTABLE - Half-sleeve foot pads have an ergonomic design, do not slip, have no unpleasant odor,...
  • REUSABLE - Thanks to high-quality breathable material metatarsal ball is suitable for daily use and...

2/ Methods to fix cowboy boots are loose on the heels

Besides the instep, it is important that the heels of cowboy boots also fit.

When you put on your cowboy boots, listen to the “pop”, which is the perfect sound coming from your heels and cowboy boots.

But if you don’t hear this sound, there is a problem…

Cowboy boots are loose in the heels, we need to find ways to make them fit tighter.

Method 1: Use heel inserts

Heel That Pain Plantar Fasciitis Insoles | Heel Seats Foot Orthotic Inserts, Heel Cups for Heel Pain and Heel Spurs | Patented, Clinically Proven, 100% Guaranteed | Blue, Medium (W 6.5-10, M 5-8)
  • FAST AND NATURAL PAIN RELIEF FOR YOUR FEET - Ideal treatment for plantar fasciitis, heel spurs, bone...
  • DESIGNED BY DOCTORS AND CLINICALLY PROVEN - Re-align the plantar fascia ligament that spans the sole...
  • OUR FIRMEST INSERTS FOR MAXIMUM RESULTS - The Original Heel Seats are made of an extra firm...

There are many different types of heel inserts, all of them can be used to fix the loose heels of your cowboy boots.

Just use heel grips to insert in cowboy boots, the contact area between your heels and cowboy boots will increase.

Besides, heel inserts also help protect your heels from blistering, from slipping, reduce heel pain when wearing boots all day long…

Read more: Best Cowboy Boot Heel Inserts

Dr. Foot’s Heel Grips for Men and Women, Self-Adhesive Heel Cushion Inserts Prevent Heel Slipping, Rubbing, Blisters, Foot Pain, and Improve Shoe Fit- 2pairs (Black)
  • HEEL PAIN RELIEF: The heel grips protect and support your heels from pain, blisters, and rubbing,...
  • COMFORTABLE DESIGN: The soft, ergonomic design replicates the contour of your heels, cushioning them...
  • HIGH-QUALITY MATERIAL: Super sticky backing is made from CROWN #513 double-sided tape to prevent...

Method 2: Use thick socks

Thick socks are multi-purpose to solve wearing problems.

Wearing a pair of thick socks will help your heels fit better than not wearing them. Besides, thick socks reduces unpleasant smell from sweat (for the boots and your feet) and prevent blisters…

WANDER Men's Cushion Crew Socks 3-6 Pairs Athletic Running 8-13/12-15 Socks Men Cotton Sport Wicking Work
  • Material: The mid calf crew socks made from 92.5% Cotton 6.7% Polyester 0.8%Spandex. Suggest machine...
  • Comfort: Smooth toe seam and stereo Y-heel, full cushion soft towel fabrics suit for ultimate...
  • Features: Thick, soft, stretch and stay up well. Perfect if you are working hard or just daily wear....

3/ Methods to fix cowboy boots with too long and wide toe

If the tip of cowboy boots are too far from your toes, then it is also difficult to fit the heel of cowboy boots. In this case, it will cause many discomforts such as heel slippage…

So how do your toes fit tighter with the cowboy boots?

Method 1: Insert cotton ball, toilet paper, soft cloth into toe box

That’s all you need! Look in your home for items such as a soft cloth, cotton ball, or toilet paper to tuck them into the toe box of cowboy boots.

Doing so will shorten the distance of the tip of cowboy boots and your toes. From there, it helps your feet fit tighter with cowboy boots.

Cotton Balls Organic by Sky Organics (100 ct.) Fragrance & Chlorine-Free Cotton Balls, 100% Jumbo Absorbent Cotton Balls & Natural Cotton Balls for Nail & Make-up Removal
  • Contains: 1 pack of 100 Organic Cotton Balls
  • Mindfully Made: 100% Cruelty-Free
  • Made with GOTS Certified Cotton & Chlorine and Fragrance-Free

Method 2: Use heel grips

This is also a good way to push your feet closer to the tip of cowboy boots. It can also help your instep fit better with cowboy boots.

Hotop 6 Pairs Heel Cushion Pads Heel Shoe Grips Liner Self-adhesive Shoe Insoles Foot Care Protector (Multicolor)
  • Good stickiness: the heel cushion pads feature with good stickiness favorable to keep them in place...
  • Rational design: the heel liners adopt hollow cylinder design to adjust the space automatically;...
  • Protective tools: these heel cushion pads are made of soft sponge, good for reducing the friction...

4/ Methods to fix the width of cowboy boots

In fact, when choosing cowboy boots, the two most important positions to fit are the instep and heel.

As for the width of boots, you should leave enough room at the ball of the boots for your feet to be comfortable.

What if the ball of cowboy boots are too loose for your feet?

Read more: Best Looking Square Toe Boots

Method 1: Use Forefoot Cushion Pads

Using forefoot cushion pads will increase the width of your foot, then forefoot can fit cowboy boots tightly.

In addition, forefoot cushion pads also relieve the pain in the ball of foot. You can use cowboy boots all day without foot pain.

Read more: Best Ariat Boot Inserts

ZenToes Metatarsal Pads for Women and Men - 4 Pack Ball of Foot Cushions
  • Unisex Fit – This 4-pack of gel metatarsalgia dancer pads fit men’s size 6-9 and women’s 8-11...
  • Reduce Friction & Discomfort – Alleviate pain due to calluses, bunions, corns, sesamoiditis or...
  • 4 Pack of Comforting Foot Supports – Relieves pressure on the ball of your foot by providing...

Method 2: Use thick socks

We are here again! Using thick socks can solve the wide problems of cowboy boots.

However, if cowboy boots are too wide, this method might be useless.

Dickies Women's Dritech Advanced Moisture Wicking Crew Sock (6/12, Black Assorted (6 Pairs), Shoe Size: 5-7
  • Moisture Wicking Fibers Keep Feet Dry with Ventilation Channels Engineered for Air Circulation and...
  • Arch Compression Provides Added Support and Stability
  • Reciprocated Heel and Toe for Superior Fit and Comfort

Some other tips to fix loose cowboy boots

  • For loose cowboy boots, your feet may slip inside the boots. If that happens, try wearing non-slip socks of yoga people, it will work well.
STOPSOCKS Non Slip Hospital Socks with Grips for Yoga, Barre, Pilates, Gym
  • WORLD’S BEST MULTI-SOCK – Forget ill-fitting hospital gripper socks you’ll never wear again....
  • WALK & WORK OUT SAFELY – Your no slip socks will keep you standing steady on any slick surface,...
  • SUPPORTIVE ANTI-SLIP SOLE – Pick the sticky socks that prevent slips, promote balance, and provide...
  • In addition to using the above items to tuck into cowboy boots, you can also use household items (cotton, soft cloth, toilet paper…) to insert into cowboy boots to make them fit tighter.

Some notes

There are some tips online that you should dip both cowboy boots into the water and dry them to make them shrink. No, don’t ever do that!.

Cowboy boots are mostly made from leather, and leather don’t love water at all. Without proper care, cowboy boots made from leather can be completely damaged.

So the idea of shrinking your boots by plunging them into the water and waiting until it is dry is so WRONG, it just destroys your boots!

Another WRONG way is to put on WET socks with WET cowboy boots at the same time, wait for both of them to dry with the hope that they will drink after that.

Well, it is not necessary to take this risk since it’s really harmful to your feet.

Anyway, the water method to shrink cowboy boots is something uncertain. We think that water will soften cowboy boots. And once you put these cowboy boots on and go, they will probably stretch rather than shrink.

Read more: How To Break In Ariat Cowboy Boots

Before you leave

Through this article and the article “How to stretch cowboy boots“, we can see that there are more ways to stretch cowboy boots than to make them shrink.

In general, we should limit the use of water or other non-specialized products for cowboy boots.

The products we introduce to you above are specialized products used for shoes, boots,…

If the above methods still don’t work, you should consider changing new cowboy boots or going to professional repair shops, they might have a way.

Good luck!

[FAQ] Should cowboy boots be tight at first?

No, they shouldn’t be cramped in the first place.

The nature of cowboy boots was born to serve the wild cowboys on the vast grass, they must withstand sun, rain, harsh weather…

So cowboy boots are very durable and sturdy, if you buy tight cowboy boots in the beginning, it will take a long time or a lot of efforts to stretch them.

So you need to choose boots with the heel and instep that snugly fit, these are the two most important areas. As long as the heel and instep fit snugly, it doesn’t matter whether other positions are wide or not.

Should cowboy boots be a little loose?

Yes. cowboy boots need to be little loose in leather around the calf, ball of the feet and toe box.

Again, you should choose cowboy boots that snugly fit at the heel and instep. Cowboy boots that are loose on the instep or heel will result in the heel slippage. This will adversely affect your gait and your comfort.

As long as the heel and instep of the cowboy boots fit snugly, it is no big deal if the rest is a bit wide.

Since the heel and instep of cowboy boots hold your foot tightly, your foot can’t slip anywhere.

In fact, you need to leave a little room at the ball, leather around the calf and toe box to wear cowboy boots comfortably.

We have a very thorough article on how to choose cowboy boots here.

How much heel slip is normal in boots?

In fact, it’s impossible to completely avoid heel slippage when wearing cowboy boots. Heel slippage somehow makes you more comfortable when wearing boots. But heel slippage should happen within allowed limits.

For newly purchased cowboy boots, 1/4″ – 3/8″ of slippage is normal. So don’t worry.

You can see more tips and methods to fix heel slippage here.

Leave a Comment